Mulder and Scully Revisited IX (AKA Scully, Skinner, Doggett, Reyes...and Mulder!)

The ninth season wasn't very highly revered by critics and fans, but I still think the show did the best they could without the character of Mulder. This season had a few episodes that focused primarily on Doggett and Reyes, and I think they worked better than the ones that didn't. Trust No 1 teased us with Mulder's possible return at a train station, only for him to be yanked away without so much as a smile. A shadowy figure running through the dark was all we got. It could have been a series highlight, but it was clumsy in its execution and we all knew that Duchovny wasn't returning until the finale anyway. Said episode, The Truth, was a tad disappointing too, acting like a bit of a summary of the series, rather than an ending. I quite liked the addition of Cary Elwes in the role of A.D. Folmer, and Lucy Lawless' appearances in the first two episodes are great. I know her pregnancy stopped her from appearing in the rest of the season, but I think she would have been a great recurring character.

The latest X-Files revival has been and gone, and for the most part, I enjoyed it. I know not every X-Phile was happy with them, but I thought it was great to see Mulder and Scully again. Anyway, back to season nine...

**Warning: spoilers ahead**

4-D (9ABx05)
The idea that parallel worlds exist is not a new one, but I like the notion that two Doggetts can't be in this dimension. In another realm, Agent Doggett tracks a serial killer and unknowingly crosses over into our world, which rips away our Agent Doggett. Confused? It makes more sense when you watch it. I like how Reyes has to convince the hospitalised and otherworldly Doggett of her theory. The hows and whys of how the killer can travel through dimensions is never really addressed, but it doesn't matter. It just happens, and it's how Reyes and Doggett II deal with it that's important.

JOHN DOE (9ABx07)
One of my favourite episodes of the Doggett era. Waking up somewhere in Mexico, Doggett has now idea where he is, how he got there or who he is. Not an original idea, but the execution is excellent. The episode was also obviously influenced by Steven Soderbergh's 2000 film Traffic, with the Mexican scenes very harshly lit. When Doggett finally remembers who he is towards the end of the episode, he has to relive his son's death all over again. It's a truly heartbreaking scene with horrible timing, as he and Reyes are in the middle of a shoot-out. Robert Patrick's performance is flawless. This is everything that was good in the ninth season, and it was written by Vince Gilligan too! It acts as a great stepping stone to the Breaking Bad series.

AUDREY PAULEY (9ABx13)
After being hit by a drunk driver, Monica Reyes is hospitalised, and soon falls into a coma. She wakes up in a phantom hospital that is suspended in space with two other patients, and they assume that they have passed away. Meanwhile, Scully tells Doggett that the comatose Reyes is braindead, which he refuses to believe. This is easily the best Reyes-centric episode of the series and an engrossing watch to boot.  It also benefits greatly from Tracey Ellis' wonderful performance as the title character (you might remember her as Lucy Householder in the third season episode Oubliette). 

WILLIAM (9ABx17)
The arrival of a mysterious man, who may or may not be Mulder (and has no qualms about laying into Skinner), sets off a chain reaction that ultimately ends with Scully deciding to give up William for adoption. While it does turn out to be Jeffrey Spender, the episode confirms for the audience that the Cigarette Smoking Man is definitely the father of both Mulder and Spender. I like the whole "is he?/isn't he?" conceit of this outing too. Although Mulder only appears briefly on screen, the episode was directed by David Duchovny himself.

RELEASE (9ABx16)
I really enjoyed Robert Patrick's role as John Doggett throughout the last two seasons. I was disappointed to learn that his character wouldn't return to the tenth, but understandably, Patrick says he's not one to look back and revisit old characters. As the season was close to wrapping up, it seemed fitting the resolve the story of Doggett's son. Jared Poe's performance as the detached, but psychic, FBI Cadet Rudolph Hayes also makes this episode a memorable one. I also like seeing Elwes' shaking A.D. Folmer after taking revenge on the man who had extorted him for so long. Patrick's acting in this outing is excellent as well, although he didn't hit as high as he did in John Doe.
HONORABLE MENTIONS: Improbable, Provenance, Sunshine Days and The Truth.

STINKERS: Jump The Shark, Underneath and Trust No 1.

Mulder and Scully Revisited VII

It's getting to the pointy end of 201 Days of The X-Files now! We're right near the end of the ninth season in our viewing now. Mulder and Scully have given way to Doggett and Reyes, but Scully is still around, as is Skinner. No Mulder until the last episode. But, let's look back two seasons ago, like I've been doing. The seventh series is lauded by some as the series' pinnacle. This could be due to how different the show became after Mulder's disappearance (catalysed by Duchovny's desire to leave). Anyway, here's my five favourites from season seven...

**Warning: spoilers ahead**

CLOSURE (7ABx11)
A strong contender for my favourite X-Files episode ever, as Samantha's fate is finally unveiled. I'm sure there were many who felt disappointed in this revelation, as it had nothing at all to do with an alien abduction. The episode before this, Sein und Zeit, was another great offering, and the way the plot shifted from a typical "monster-of-the-week" story into a Samantha one was just brilliant. I also quite liked Anthony Heald's performance as Harold Piller, the psychic that offers his help to Mulder. Piller's refusal to acknowledge his own son's fate is just as heartbreaking as Mulder's acceptance. The use of Moby's song My Weakness is eerily exceptional; it's so haunting. When I heard that music again during the episode it brought back all the feelings from the last time I viewed it. The whys and hows of what happened to Samantha aren't as important as Mulder finally knowing. The final words of the episode are Mulder's response to Scully when she asks how he is: "I'm fine. I'm free." As the title says, he gets closure and can now move on. 

X-COPS (7ABx12)
The merging of The X-Files with reality TV show Cops was a stroke of genius, and who better to write the script than Vince Gilligan? I'm a big fan of how the cameras follow the action, and it's like we're not just viewers, we're participants. Watching Mulder and Scully look into the cameras is hilarious too. I love how Scully initially wants nothing to do with it, and then mugs for the camera as the episode continues: "Because the FBI has nothing to hide." Mulder seems to be a lot more comfortable with the situation and plays up to cameras beautifully, even giving the show's staple monologues a crack. What starts out as a hunt for some kind of monster gives way to an even scarier premise. Great episode!

HOLLYWOOD A.D. (7ABx18)
David Duchovny's second go at writing and directing an episode is a great romp that manages to lampoon movie studios, pop culture and religious relics. The appearances of Garry Shandling and Téa Leoni are fantastic too, as they play Mulder and Scully in the film version of the episode's events. It's a very funny outing with some great scenes and wonderful dialogue. My favourite moment is the three-way split screen of Mulder, Scully and Skinner in a bubble bath (separate ones). Put simply, I just find the episode a lot of fun to watch.

JE SOUHAITE (7ABx21)This episode was the directing debut of Vince Gilligan who also wrote the script. I remembered this entry as being fairly good, but I forgot just how funny it was. I laughed harder than any other episode in the seventh season. The sheer stupidity of Anson Stokes and his brother as they struggle to come up with decent wishes from a rug-living jinn, or genie, is truly hilarious.  It's dismissed by some as a bit of fluff, but I think it's hugely entertaining.

REQUIEM (7ABx22)
The season finale does a great job of bookending the series to that point. Harking back to elements and characters from the pilot episode, this outing quite rightly draws a circle around the entire show. We get to see Krycek, Cigarette Smoking Man and Marita Covarrubias again as well. From this point on, everything about the show changes, as Mulder's abduction signals Duchovny's departure. He would star in twelves episodes of the eighth season (roughly) and only the two-part final of season nine. The cliffhanger ending is all the more poignant for Mulder ultimately gets proof of alien life, but at the cost of abduction.

HONOURABLE MENTIONS: The Goldberg Variation, Sein und Zeit, En Ami and The Sixth Extinction II: Amor Fati.

STINKERS: all things (sorry, Gillian!), Chimera and Fight Club. 

Mulder and Scully Revisited V

Well, we've made some pretty decent headway into the seventh season now, so I thought I'd do my usual look back, two seasons ago. I think the fifth was a pretty strong season, and had some great episodes. Let me expand...

**Warning: spoilers ahead**

REDUX II (5x02)
Aside from the reveal of what actually happened in Mulder's apartment that night, the first Redux episode was a bit of a snoozefest, in my mind. So much monologuing! It continually cuts from Mulder to Scully and back again, and each time they deliver a scene with a big long voiceover. The first two episodes of the fifth season should have been siphoned into one kick-ass opener. Thankfully, this episode is fantastic. The race is on to save Scully's life, and Mulder struggles with what he believes in. The way events ramp up to all the revelations in the end are just great too. Assassinations! Truths! And of course, questions and ambiguous deaths!

THE POST-MODERN PROMETHEUS (5x06)
This episode is a favourite of many, and I'm happy to jump on the bandwagon. From its black and white cinematography to its fascination with Cher to its Frankenstein homage, it's a home run on all counts. Managing to feel like an X-File episode, it isn't like one we've ever seen before (and since, might I add). Written and directed by series creator Chris Carter, this could arguably be his best work. 

BAD BLOOD (5x12)
I was worried that I had built this episode up too much, but it totally delivered! The idea of having the same events shown through both Mulder and Scully eyes was a masterstroke, and the humour in this episode is simply terrific. Vince Gilligan's hilarious script tackles obsessive-compulsive vampires, multiple autopsies, freewheelin' RVs and stars the always-charming Luke Wilson. While it can be seen is a riff on Akira Kurasowa's Rashomon, it stands up as its own beast. I tend to lean towards the humourous episodes when I think of my favourites, and this outing just might be the funniest. The way Mulder and Scully see each other after working with each other for five years border on caricature, but never lapse into imitation or mockery. This is still in my Top 5 X-Files episodes ever.

THE PINE BLUFF VARIANT (5x18)
Now this one is probably one of the least X-files-like episodes produced, but I love it. I particularly dig the way that we are thrown midway into the story and are almost immediately questioning Mulder's motives. Whose side is he on? Could he be a traitor? It's more like a spy film than anything else. When Mulder is tortured by the people he's trying to prove loyal to, it's a real slap to the face. We've not seen such brutality before, and Mulder's retaliation is equally brutal. There are numerous twists and turns to the plot which deals with an anarchistic milita called The New Spartans, and their development of a lethal biological weapon. Yeah, it's a good one.

THE END (5x20)
I really liked the addition of Gibson Praise, a young boy who can read other people's thoughts. His insights have the clarity of a psychic mixed with the innocence of a child. Is he an alien/human hybrid? How can he read thoughts?The fact that Gibson himself could be the key to everything in the X-Files makes for a great game of cat and mouse. The opening scene features this character playing chess in a large sports stadium, and it's one of my favourite sequences. This episode is also notable for the introduction of Diana Fowley (played by Mimi Rogers), whose job on The X-Files is to either annoy Scully (and us!) while tangling herself around her old flame, Mulder. Mimi does a good job of playing her, but I don't think much of the character. It doesn't stop me from loving this season cliffhanger, which includes the bombshell of Agent Spender learning that the Cigarette Smoking Man is his father. The final scenes of Mulder's office (and the X-Files themselves) on fire is one of the most powerful images from the entire series.


HONOURABLE MENTIONS: Kill Switch, Patient X and Christmas Carol.

STINKERS: Redux, Chinga and Kitsunegari.

Mulder and Scully Revisited IV

We're enthusiastically making our way through the sixth season at the moment, which means I should be blogging about my five favourite episodes of the fourth season! Yes, indeedy! We also watched The X-Files Movie again, which held up pretty damn well, in my mind. But, let's go back a bit, shall we?

**Warning: spoilers ahead**

PAPER HEARTS (4x08)
This episode has so many things going for it; the dream sequences, the possibility of knowing what happened to Samantha, Tom Noonan's amazingly brilliant and underplayed turn as serial killer John Lee Roche, the climatic scene in the bus depot...it's just stunning. Written by Vince Gilligan with Noonan in mind to play Roche, it might be my favourite of the fourth season. The way Mulder's memories are manipulated by Roche, and the constant 'did he?/didn't he?' undercurrent make it stand out from the usual X-Files fare.  I just can't speak highly enough of this one.

MEMENTO MORI (4x15)
Scully's battle with cancer sees her undergo treatment and spend time in hospital while Mulder desperately searches for a cure. He even considers making a deal with the Cigarette Smoking Man, until Skinner strongly advises him against such an action. Watching Scully come to terms with what is happening to her body is one of the most heartbreaking moments in the whole series. Mulder's little covert raid with the Lone Gunmen is another big highlight too. 

TEMPUS FUGIT (4x17)
I love that Max Fenig returned to the show, (albeit only for two episodes, and even then, he's hardly in them) and I dug the whole concept of trying to piece together the final events of Flight 549. Scary Moustache Man (as I call him) makes for a nice mysterious villain too. If only Tom Selleck was available for the role! The concluding episode Max is also good, but the sheer scale of recreating an aerial crash site puts this entry slightly ahead. I love that title translates to 'time flies' as well.

SMALL POTATOES (4x20)
Another cracking episode from Vince Gilligan that is filled with humour as we follow Darin Morgan as Eddie Van Blundht, a man who can assume the shape of any other person. I thought I had remembered this episode as being better than it actually was, but my recent viewing confirmed its status as one the series' best, in my opinion. One of my favourite moments occurs when Mulder and Scully knock on the door of Van Blundht's father's house. Throughout the episode he constantly corrects the spelling of his surname, in that it has a 'D' in it. After the home's door is struck, the 'D' from the lettering bearing the family name on door falls off. It's so subtle, that you might have missed it, but it cracked me up.

GETHSEMANE (4x24)
This episode is pretty polarising, as its cliffhanger ending would have us believe that Mulder has become so disillusioned and lost that he has taken his own life. While that's too extreme a notion for some to entertain, surely most viewers would have seen the truth that was revealed in the season five opening episode coming. As if Mulder would die. Remember the Anasazi cliffhanger? I can see how his character could have considered that option. The episode pretty much tears down all the things he was lead to believe over the last four years (or did it?) and the truth he thought he desperately came close to uncovering was in fact the biggest lie of all. In addition to that, his hope to one day learn the truth about his sister's disappearance seemed further from his grasp than ever. Written by Chris Carter himself, I love the way the plot unfolds via Scully's narration at the FBI hearing. For me, the image of the big rectangular table all lit up is synonymous with this episode. Gillian Anderson's role as the narrator and participant of the story is also very well done, and I think her performance while revealing Mulder's 'fate' at the end is quite excellent. The discovery of the alien body and all the other facets of the mythology in this outing are hugely entertaining too. There many religious overtones throughout as well, not least being the title. Another highlight for me is the first appearance of Michael Kritschgau, played by John Finn. I have no problem citing this as one of my five favourites.


HONOURABLE MENTIONS: Home, Unruhe, Musings of a Cigarette-Smoking Man, Tunguska and Max.

STINKERS: The Field Where I Died (my vote for the worst X-Files episode of all time) and El Mundo Gira.

Mulder and Scully Revisited III

Okay, so it's time to look back on the third season now. We've just finished off the fifth season, which is probably my favourite. That means while be watching The X-Files Movie in our next session! I don't know why I need a two-season buffer, but it seems to serve me well. Let's get down to my five picks...

**Warning: spoilers ahead**

CLYDE BRUCKMAN'S FINAL REPOSE (3x04)
Darin Morgan's second offering for The X-Files is just as entertaining as season two's Humbug, arguably even more so. I think part of this is due to Peter Boyle's effortlessly brilliant performance as the title character. His interactions with the ever-dubious Scully are just wonderful. The dialogue between the police feels like something out of a cartoon at times, which adds to the outlandish atmosphere. Why is it that the best episodes are the ones that veer away from the classic X-Files formulas? Not that this is wildly different, as there is still a paranormal undercurrent within Boyle's psychic Bruckman. With striking images, quotable lines and unforgettable final scene, this would probably be in my top five episodes of the entire series.

731 (3x10)
While I quite enjoyed the preceding Nisei episode, it's after Mulder jumps onto the train (which Duchovny did himself apparently) that the action and suspense starts to build. I love the scenes between Mulder and Stephen McHattie's Red Haired Man. It reminds me of Sean Connery and Robert Shaw in the final act of From Russia With Love. The fact that X pulls his finger out and actually does something to help Mulder is pretty cool too.

PUSHER (3x17)
Written by Breaking Bad creator Vince Gilligan, this episode looks at Robert Patrick Modell, a man who can push his will onto others. Unfortunately for those he comes into contact with, this usually means death by their own hand. As Modell eludes capture, the cat and mouse game he plays with Mulder comes to a head with an emotional round of Russian roulette. You'll never look at cerulean blue the same way again. Suspenseful stuff!


JOSE CHUNG'S "FROM OUTER SPACE" (3x20)

The third script from Darin Morgan is another X-Files classic. It's told through the eyes of the title character as he puts together a book detailing the alleged alien abduction of two teenagers in Klass County. Each person he talks to has a different take on the events that occured, and some re-tellings are quite hilarious. One witness recounts Mulder's visit to a diner wherein he orders piece after piece of sweet potato pie. Another's description of the two agents paints Scully as angry and violent with red hair that is "a little TOO red". Jesse "The Body" Ventura guest stars as one of the mysterious Men In Black, and delivers an excellent monologue on how most people mistake the planet Venus for a UFO. This episode also has some clever editing and is highly entertaining. One of the best!


TALITHA CUMA (3x24)
The season finale introduces to Jeremiah Smith, a man who possess the ability to heal gunshot victims, among others. But is he human? As this essential mythology episode unravels we learn that Mulder's mother and the Cigarette Smoking Man have a history. The discovery of an alien stiletto weapon in the Mulders' old summer home gives us more questions about Mrs Mulder's past. This episode has two great scenes in it. The first being Jeremiah Smith's interrogation by the CSM, in which he morphs into characters from CSM's past, adding weight to his words. The second is the fight between Mulder and X which ends in the two of them drawing their guns on each other. While he has always been nervous and cautious, X's motives seem to be more about self-preservation than assisting Mulder. When X actually tries to help him in the season four opener Herrenvolk, it ends badly, justifying his paranoia. This is one of the best mythology episodes of the series, with a nice taut cliffhanger ending to boot. I really wanted to have Apocrypha in my five, purely for the scene of Krycek 'crying' the black oil out of his body before being locked in the silo, but it didn't quite make the cut.


HONOURABLE MENTIONS: Nisei, Apocrypha, War of The Coprophages and Syzygy.

STINKERS: Teso Dos Bichos, that's it. The only really awful episode of this season; and it's a doozy.