Week: Tue 8th to Mon 14th October 2019
Format: CD/iPod
Producer(s): Phil Collins and Hugh Padgham
Track listing:
1. I Don't Care Anymore *
2. I Cannot Believe That It's True
3. Like China *
4. Do You Know, Do You Care?
5. You Can't Hurry Love
6. It Don't Matter To Me
7. Thru These Walls *
8. Don't Let Him Steal Your Heart Away *
9. The West Side
10. Why Can't It Wait Til Morning
TOTAL RUNNING TIME: 45:03
I'd lost touch with Phil's output after Dance Into The Light, and wasn't overly interested in his work for Disney, but I thought I was a pretty full bottle until 1993 or so. I was surprised that six songs from Hello, I Must Be Going! were included on The Singles, and I only knew one of them, which was his cover of You Can't Hurry Love. That song was the only track from H,IMBG! that appeared on Serious Hits... Live! as well.
Anyway, fast forward past the concert (which was awesome), and I decided to use some JB Hi-Fi vouchers which I had accrued to acquire more Phil. I managed to grab the limited edition 8CD Take a look at me now... boxset which housed all of Phil's solo studio albums. Each one had been remastered and reissued in 2015, complete with newly recreated covers featuring Phil at his current age. I was stoked to finally have a decent copy of Face Value, after nearly wearing out my dad's vinyl and I had Both Sides on cassette once upon a time, so I felt it was worth having the lot. As of writing this, I've had the set for nearly eight months, and I still haven't listened to the last three albums.
I've been spending a lot of time with H,IMBG! recently as I've really started to appreciate the album that it is. A few months back, a friend of mine told me that his three-year-old son had been drumming along perfectly to the track Thru These Walls, and I couldn't place it. It wasn't sounding familiar to me, so I made a note back then to give Phil's difficult second album a decent spin. I think it was a fairly staggered affair though, as I seemed to latch on to some songs and keep listening to them, in essence ignoring over half the record.
The aforementioned Thru These Walls has become a big favourite of mine now, and although it has been unfairly labelled as simply retreading In The Air Tonight, it is quite different as far as melody, structure and theme go. Sure the intro, is similar, but the chords are different! And yes, the repeated drum fill is almost identical to ITAT (right down to the replicated gated reverb), but the song's narrative about a guy listening to the amorous couple in the room next door is far from the anger and rage in the former. Anyway, I dig it. I wish I wasn't so late to the party.The first time I heard the opening track I Don't Care Anymore, was on the rock radio station of Grand Theft Auto V. I was struck by Phil Collins' voice and the realisation that I didn't know the song. I wasn't even sure if it was Collins solo or Genesis. Now it's become another highlight of this album for me. Although it feels like the climax never really arrives, I love the venom in Collins' vocal performance. Looking past the clichéd lyrics, the drums sound great (very 80's) and each listen seems to improve the song. As if knowing the build peaks with Phil's vocal compensates for a big musical pay-off. The record's second song I Cannot Believe That It's True and It Don't Matter To Me fit nicely into his blue-eyed soul work, complete with brass lines by The Phenix Horns. Indeed, the album swings from jaunty pop numbers to menacing, moody pieces which is typified by the transition from the dark Do You Know, Do You Care? to You Can't Hurry Love. Juxtapose much? Big fan, me.
One of my go-to tracks on this album is Like China, which sees Phil adopt the persona of a teenage boy trying to woo a girl he's become infatuated with. There's hooks-aplenty here, and I love the emphasis on the guitar. Phil puts on a Cockney accent to add to the fun too. Although, on first listen, you're questioning (excuse me?) what the actual lyrics in the chorus are. They go like this:
"I'll be so careful I'll hold you like china/
I'll promise not to hurt you I'll hold you like china..."
Don't Let Him Steal Your Heart Away was a song that had to grow on me a little, but I love it now. As the title suggests, it deals with someone pleading with their ex-lover not to give up on their relationship and ditch Mr Right Time (with the Right Smile) who swooped in to pick up the pieces. When the drums kick in, it seems to lift from a soppy ballad into something a bit poppier, with a little swing. The piano in the refrain helps the song shuffle along nicely too.
I feel that the album does fizzle a little towards the end. The (mostly) instrumental track The West Side has some nice moments, but seems to outstay its welcome a bit. An issue rectified on Saturday Night and Sunday Morning from 1989's But Seriously... which doesn't even break the one and a half minute mark. The record closes with Why Can't It Wait Til Morning, which hasn't endeared itself to me yet. It was released as single in the UK (his fifth from this album) but it just doesn't move me. Such a shame, because the rest of H,IMBG! is quite strong.
While not the masterpiece that Face Value is, Phil's difficult second album is certainly a more-than-worthy addition to his catalog. Some of the turmoil he had experienced during the breakdown of his first marriage seeps into this record, but not to the same degree as Face Value. Some songs are a bit more fun, and obviously his love of Motown and old R&B/soul fueled his decision to cover The Supremes. To great chart success, at that.
Now, should I give Dance Into The Light a spin..?
