I Never Loved a Man the Way I Love You ARETHA FRANKLIN (1967)
Week: Fri 9th to Thu 15th May, 2025
Format: vinyl, iPod
Producer: Jerry Wexler
Tracklisting:
1. Respect *
2. Drown in My Own Tears
3. I Never Loved a Man (the Way I Love You) *
4. Soul Serenade
5. Don't Let Me Lose This Dream
6. Baby, Baby, Baby
7. Dr Feelgood (Love is a Serious Business) *
8. Good Times
9. Do Right Woman, Do Right Man *
10. Save Me
11. A Change is Gonna Come *
TOTAL RUNNING TIME: 32:27
I first listened to this album in 2012, as part of the awesome music blog project I was a part of called afyccim. The word was an acronym for 'a five year crash course in music', and there were four of us writing reviews on albums. Each year we concentrated on a decade, listening to one long player a week. One of us would write the main review, and the other three would supplement the entry with mini reviews. It was an awesome experience, but we only got to about halfway through the 80s. The 60s and 70s reviews are still up on the old WordPress site. In fact, click here for our review of this album, which coincidentally was our very first one.
Anyway, I was quite impressed by the record. It was a great introduction to a bit more of her music. I only knew Respect (of course) and the two tracks featured in The Commitments, Do Right Woman, Do Right Man and the title song. It's an enjoyable listen, and then moved on to our next album, which was The Band's Music From Big Pink.
Fast forward a few years and I become enamoured by a 20th anniversary vinyl release of The Flaming Lips' excellent album The Soft Bulletin. It was being reissued by a company called Vinyl Me, Please and was an exclusive product that was only available from their online store. There were a number of ways to get it, but the most appealing option was to buy a three month membership to VMP, where I would get sent a LP a month for that time. After checking the other two releases, I signed up and surrendered our bank details. They were Queens of the Stone Age's Songs for the Deaf (on double red vinyl) and this album I am blogging about right now.
The Aretha album was the last one of the three, and it was delayed in arriving. Possibly due to the Christmas rush/crush, I was notified that it was on its way in early December 2019, but it didn't arrive until February the following year. No matter. It's a lovely reissue with a lyric booklet, a photo from the recording and spekky, swirled white and purple coloured vinyl. Sounds freaken great too! Over the years the album has grown on me considerably. It's not something I sought out, but I'm very glad I own it.
Not knowing much of Aretha except her big hits, I was surprised to learn that this is her tenth release, following years of being signed to Columbia Records. Enter Jerry Wexler and his Atlantic label who encouraged Aretha to search her soul and let loose. I guess it's because of her rebirth and rebranding that this album feels like a debut, and not a tenth offering. There's an energy and an excitement to Aretha's voice and the music behind her. It's like she's realising this is the music she is meant to sing.
This bold and unabashed approach begins with a searing cover of Otis Redding's Respect, which let's face it, eclipses the original version. The fact that many forget it was Redding's composition speaks volumes of how powerful and engaging Aretha's rendition is. It's not just a song, it's a rally cry, and an anthem for change. Aretha's soulful tones would become incendiary for putting the spotlight on gender equality, racial discrimination and social division. It is fitting that this album ends with a lovely version of Sam Cooke's A Change is Gonna Come, complete with a new intro in which Aretha briefly details why she was moved to sing it. Her version of Cooke's Good Times is pretty great too, which is considerably lighter in tone.
In addition to feminist anthems and calls for change, Aretha gets down with her bad self on several tracks. There's a funky groove on tracks like Save Me and Dr Feelgood (Love is a Serious Business) that gets your feet tapping. The mood is dialed back to melancholy longing for Drown In My Own Tears and Don't Let Me Lose This Dream without sacrificing the soulful feel of the album.
My absolute favourite songs remain the title track and Do Right Woman, Do Right Man. As I stated previously, I was familiar with The Commitments' versions before hearing Aretha perform them, and I can see why they were picked for the film. While the renditions for the The Commitments movie are good, these ones are gold. Bizarrely, I would also come to love another version of Do Right Woman, Do Right Man courtesy of affycim when we listened to The Flying Burrito Brothers' wonderful album The Gilded Palace of Sin from 1969. Rather than the R&B ballad treatment it gets here, the FBB scale it down into a slower, early alt-country rock swinger. Both versions are terrific, each with their own merits, and each feel right for the artist.
When Aretha sings that she has never loved a man the way she loves you, it's transcendent. As the band stop to give her the a cappela line, she infuses it with desire and longing that's just riveting. When she launches into the bridge with "I can't sleep at night..." and the musicians take off with her, it's a brilliant moment, and arguably the highlight of the entire album. If you've not given this a spin, do right by yourself and change that. The only criticism I have is that is all over in less than thirty five minutes. This record takes you on an exquisite journey, and like most enjoyable rides, it is all over too soon.